By Sam van de Schootbrugge 24-06-2020

Rethinking Stock Valuations Using A Bond Dividend Approach

(5 min read)
Resize text:


The global economy’s problematic re-emergence from the Great Recession revived interest in Alvin Hansen’s 1939 secular stagnation hypothesis. Hansen coined the term to refer to the period of low growth prospects during the 1930s, which came on the back of slowing innovation and an ageing population. The parallels between the economic fundamentals of then and the last decade led Larry Summers to surmise that an era of protracted spells of low growth and low (nominal and real) interest rates would ensue. Indeed, rates across maturities have dropped to all-time low levels around the world.

An NBER working paper, ‘Duration-Based Stock Valuation’, adds to the growing literature examining the impact that these discount rate shocks have had on financial markets. Specifically, the author Jules van Binsbergen pays attention to the valuation of long duration assets by constructing several counterfactual fixed income portfolios that match dividend strips of the aggregate stock market. Counter to two anomalies found in the literature, the equity premium puzzle and the excess volatility puzzle, the following results are presented:

Between 1996 and 2020, a fixed income investor would have achieved similar, and likely substantially better, return performance than an investor in the S&P500 index. Expanding the horizon from 1970 to 2020 and to the Eurostoxx, the results remain valid. As such, Binbergen concludes that investors have received little to no compensation for taking long duration nominal dividend risk over the last fifty years.

TO READ THIS DEEP DIVE
SUBSCRIBE TO MACRO HIVE PRIME

£39/month thereafter

For access to our Slack Chat Room, where we discuss all things markets with our researchers and subscribers

START YOUR FREE TRIAL


MOST READ

ECB Preview: Biding Time Until June (2 min read)

By Caroline Grady | Apr 20, 2021
Stepped up PEPP purchases since the 11 March ECB meeting leave little need for any policy changes at this week’s governing council meeting...

Russia Sanctions: The Shock That Never Came (5 min read)

By Tatiana Orlova | Apr 16, 2021
The most important measure bars US entities from newly issued local sovereign debt, effective from 14 June. The ban includes debt issued by the CBR...

Weekly Vaccination Update: J&J Pause and EU Supply Schedule (1 min read)

By Sam van de Schootbrugge | Apr 14, 2021
In this prime tracker, we review the latest vaccine developments globally. This week, we’ve added some brief commentary...

PREMIUM CONTENT

ECB Preview: Biding Time Until June (2 min read)

By Caroline Grady | Apr 20, 2021
Summary Thursday’s ECB meeting is unlikely to…

Five Things You Did Not Know About China (2 min read)

By Bilal Hafeez | Apr 13, 2021
China is a global economic superpower, yet…

Want To Join Our Community Of Leading Investors And Researchers In Our Slack Chat Room?